Denison Forum – Can A.I. be my Bible study teacher?

 

How artificial intelligence could reshape the way we study Scripture

When we imagine artificial intelligence becoming dangerous, Hollywood has given us plenty to work with. Humanoid robots hunting people. Supercomputers launching nuclear missiles. Somewhere along the way, someone usually regrets giving the machine so much authority.

But a more immediate danger could arrive through something considerably less cinematic–Bad advice.

A cartoon making the rounds on social media captures the problem:A man holds up a mushroom and asks an AI robot whether it is edible. “Yes!” comes the confident reply. In the next panel, the robot stands beside the man’s gravestone. It acknowledges that the mushroom was poisonous, apologizes for the confusion, and asks, “Would you like more information about poisonous mushrooms?”

A little late for the correction. (Ironically, the cartoon is AI-generated)

The joke exposes the gap between a convincing answer and a trustworthy one. That gap deserves our attention as we bring AI into our discernment of God’s Word.

This has already moved well beyond an academic question. Recent research from Barna and Gloo found that 24 percent of Protestant pastors use AI to write or edit sermons. About one-third of practicing Christians reported turning to it for spiritual guidance or Bible questions in the previous month.

Bottom of Form

Nearly half of practicing Christians said they would trust AI’s advice for growing spiritually. Yet 83 percent also expressed concern about AI misinterpreting Scripture. Apparently, we can worry about the answers, but keep asking the questions.

An appealing study partner

The attraction is easy to understand. You encounter a confusing passage of Scripture, ask a chatbot what it means, and receive an explanation within seconds. You can request historical background, compare interpretations, or ask about an unfamiliar theological term. The AI has access to thousands of resources, including the best theologians in history.

It is available whenever you are. It never seems irritated by follow-up questions. And you can ask questions you might feel embarrassed to raise in Sunday school.

Those advantages deserve consideration. An easily accessible explanation might help someone continue reading a passage they would otherwise abandon—especially those for whom a big stack of commentaries isn’t appealing.

The harder question is how much authority we give the machine’s explanation.

Transparency is one issue. With a commentary or study Bible, we can identify the author and investigate the theological perspective behind the notes. A chatbot’s response may offer fewer clues about whose interpretation we are receiving.

Even the founder of YouVersion, the world’s largest Bible/devotional app, sees reason for caution. In a recent Christianity Today interview, Bobby Gruenewald warned that people approach AI as an oracle, assuming its polished responses reflect superior understanding. “Human beings have generally associated fluency with intelligence. So what you have is a technology that, by design, is super fluent.” But an answer’s accuracy can be difficult to judge unless we already know enough to recognize its errors—a serious concern when seeking spiritual direction or interpreting Scripture. “People lose touch with the fact that it could be greatly wrong,” Gruenewald said.

Writing for the Lausanne Movement, AI researcher Marcus Schwarting raises concerns about doctrinal and cultural biases in AI responses. He also warns that some may begin regarding a chatbot as a spiritual companion or guide. A friendly answer can make its underlying assumptions easy to overlook.

Ask about baptism, spiritual gifts, or predestination, and those assumptions matter. A reader unfamiliar with the debate may have little basis for recognizing them.

The teacher we want to hear

Another concern: How willing are we to receive an answer we dislike?

We can ask a chatbot to explain a passage. We can also ask it to build a biblical argument for a conclusion we have already reached, refining the request until the result sounds persuasive.

That temptation predates artificial intelligence. We have long been capable of shopping for teachers who agree with us. AI makes the process remarkably efficient.

A good Bible teacher sometimes makes us uncomfortable. Someone who knows us may recognize that our apparently abstract theological question has a personal motive.Such accountability can be difficult to welcome, especially when a more agreeable conversation is available on our phones.

That willingness to keep the conversation on our phones extends into difficult territory. In research published by Gloo, nearly one in four practicing Christians said AI could continue handling a spiritual crisis without connecting the person to a human helper.

A question that begins with “What does this verse mean?” can become “Does God still love me?” or “Can I ever be forgiven?” Those are moments when we may need someone who will listen, pray with us, and call again tomorrow.

Where does the Holy Spirit come in?

For Christians, this question belongs near the center of the discussion.

We approach Scripture believing that God works through it to teach, correct, and shape us. We pray for understanding because spiritual growth involves our desires and conduct as well as our knowledge.

In 1 Corinthians 2:10–14, Paul describes the Spirit’s role in revealing and enabling understanding of the things of God. That should give us pause before treating a polished explanation as the completion of our study.

Author and speaker Carey Nieuwhof, whose new book is AI and the Future Church: Make Your Ministry Irreplaceable in a World of Artificial Everything, identifies a related challenge. He writes, “AI answers every question instantly. God often doesn’t answer at all.” This observation raises an uncomfortable question. Could we become so accustomed to immediate responses that we lose patience with prayer, uncertainty, or the slow work of understanding?

God can use a commentary, a sermon, or technology to help us understand a passage. We still need to consider the habits we develop around those resources.

Do we read the passage before requesting its summary? Do we pray over what we encounter? Do we leave room for a difficult verse to unsettle us?

We could finish a study with an excellent explanation and leave the harder work of responding to it untouched.

Keep the Bible open

Acts 17:11 offers a helpful model. The Bereans welcomed Paul’s message eagerly and examined the Scriptures daily to determine whether what he said was true.

Their eagerness and their examination belonged together.

We can bring that posture to AI. Check the passage in context. Verify quotations and references. Ask which interpretations Christians dispute and why. Take significant questions into conversation with a trusted pastor or teacher.

We can also ask questions that lead us further into the text. “What should I look for as I read this chapter?” leaves us with work to do.

An AI assistant may help us locate information and consider an explanation. We remain responsible for examining what we receive and responding faithfully to God. And it’s often in the process of doing so that God reveals answers to questions we may never have thought to ask otherwise.

 

 

Denison Forum

Innovative News WEB site – https://newsfeathers.com/ – The news, with a little ruffle

 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.